Comments on: Auto Buybacks http://www.snowflakesinhell.com/2008/08/11/auto-buybacks/ Firearms Policy and Politics in Pennsylvania Thu, 18 Mar 2010 04:03:41 -0400 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: Nomen Nescio http://www.snowflakesinhell.com/2008/08/11/auto-buybacks/#comment-28090 Nomen Nescio Mon, 11 Aug 2008 22:39:24 +0000 http://www.snowflakesinhell.com/?p=4539#comment-28090 oh, come on. this idea may not make enough sense to implement, but i can think of several reasons it makes a <i>lot</i> more sense than gun buybacks. just for a few, the expected goals (reduction in pollution, improvement in gas mileage) are actually sort-of measurable and not totally incredible on the face of it; there's no particular reason to believe folks would hold back on selling their gas-guzzling clunkers, unlike criminals with guns; and, unlike disarming poor folk, this idea would be likely to <i>increase</i> social equality rather than decrease it, even if only minutely. (yes, having reliable, cheap-to-operate transportation is a social equality issue. it improves your chances to get and keep a job, for instance.) sure, it's badly misnamed. but if that were the only thing wrong with the program, i'd say go for it in a heartbeat. it's certainly far more likely to actually help people than gun "buybacks" ever are! oh, come on. this idea may not make enough sense to implement, but i can think of several reasons it makes a lot more sense than gun buybacks. just for a few, the expected goals (reduction in pollution, improvement in gas mileage) are actually sort-of measurable and not totally incredible on the face of it; there’s no particular reason to believe folks would hold back on selling their gas-guzzling clunkers, unlike criminals with guns; and, unlike disarming poor folk, this idea would be likely to increase social equality rather than decrease it, even if only minutely.

(yes, having reliable, cheap-to-operate transportation is a social equality issue. it improves your chances to get and keep a job, for instance.)

sure, it’s badly misnamed. but if that were the only thing wrong with the program, i’d say go for it in a heartbeat. it’s certainly far more likely to actually help people than gun “buybacks” ever are!

]]> By: Speakertweaker http://www.snowflakesinhell.com/2008/08/11/auto-buybacks/#comment-28052 Speakertweaker Mon, 11 Aug 2008 17:08:50 +0000 http://www.snowflakesinhell.com/?p=4539#comment-28052 Never mind the economic problems. What about the fact that the idea is fundamentally flawed to begin with? You cannot <i>buy back</i> something that you never owned in the first place. Therefore, any "buyback" program is really a "buy" program. Now that we've got that cleared up, exactly where in the hell does any government have the extra money lying around to buy up a bunch of busted cars/guns/etc.? tweaker Never mind the economic problems. What about the fact that the idea is fundamentally flawed to begin with?

You cannot buy back something that you never owned in the first place. Therefore, any “buyback” program is really a “buy” program.

Now that we’ve got that cleared up, exactly where in the hell does any government have the extra money lying around to buy up a bunch of busted cars/guns/etc.?

tweaker

]]>