Pennsylvania has one of the most clear and indisputable right to bear arms provisions of any state in the country.
The right of the citizens to bear arms in defence of themselves and the State shall not be questioned.
Dave Hardy says that a new law review article, referenced by DC and its amici, is now online for the rest of us to read. Dave says:
The main theme is to try to demonstate that Pennsylvania’s 1776 Declaration, which guaranteed the right of citizens to bear arms for defense of themselves and the state, meant something other than an individual right. The gist of the demonstration is that at the time lots of privotal Pennsylvanians were concerned about creating a mandatory militia. OK, so what? The 1776 Constitution had references to that. There’s no showing that the fact that many wanted a mandatory militia caused the right to arms clause to be inserted in the Declaration.
I won’t go into detail because the article has been critiqued in depth by Clayton Cramer and by Dave Kopel. Clayton points out that the article actually cites Bellesiles!
Unbelievable.
3 Comments »
I had totally forgotten that we were supposed to spring ahead today. It seems odd when Ohio bloggers are buried under snow. SayUncle is already preparing for spring. We didn’t get any snow in southeastern Pennsylvania, but we don’t really get nice spring weather until May, typically. March isn’t quite as cold, but still jacket and sometimes coat weather, and most of April is rainy and miserable.
2 Comments »
Bruce of No Looking Backwards says:
I’ve come to terms with the fact that Fred Thompson is not going to be the next President of the United States. I am, hereby, officially endorsing the candidacy of John McCain for President.
Granted, he is far from being the “perfect candidate”.
Then again, no such man or woman exists. And, if they do, they likely possess the common sense that would compel them to avoid running for president.
I’d say I’m about 70% in agreement with McCain on the issues. But that number drops to approximately zero when looking at what the Democrats will have to offer us this fall. I see it as a choice between a D-student and someone who never bothered to show up for class.
I have not decided yet whether to actively shill for McCain, or just beat up on his opponents mercilessly. I’m still of the opinion that McCain is far far better than either of those two, and on my big area of disagreement with him, campaign finance reform, he can probably do less further damage as president than he can remaining a senator.
13 Comments »
Clayton Cramer analyzes some of the obfuscation made by The District of Columbia in their reply brief in the Heller case.
No Comments »
Scott Bash, President of The Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs, and NRA Board Member, hits back at Bryan Miller on why New Jersey should not be throwing otherwise law abiding gun owners in prison for ten years because they are unknowingly in possession of an assault firearm.
No Comments »